A product of the Atalanta football academy, Andrea Consigli was signed by the club in 2006 and was immediately loaned to Sambenedettese of the Serie C (3rd tier). The following year, he was loaned to Serie B’s Rimini.
Consigli returned to Atalanta during the 2008-2009 season and became a regular starter. Between 2008 and 2014, he made a total 193 Serie A and Serie B starts for the team. Consigli helped Atalanta win the Serie B title in 2010-2011.
On September 1, 2014, Consigli was purchased by Serie A’s Sassuolo for a €3,000,000 transfer fee.