Liverpool’s Challenges: Analyzing Recent Defeats to PSG and Newcastle

Liverpool’s recent setbacks against Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) in the UEFA CL and Newcastle in the Carabao Cup Final have raised concerns among supporters and analysts alike. 

Despite a season that has seen them dominate domestically, these crucial defeats have highlighted underlying issues within the camp. 

Let’s go through the tactical and strategic factors contributing to Liverpool’s recent downturn. We’ll focus on physical decline, pressing inefficiencies, build-up play disruptions, Mohamed Salah’s dip in form, Ryan Gravenberch’s fatigue, and limited squad rotation. We’ll also analyze the energy-sapping period between October and December.​

Physical Decline and Fatigue

One of the most pressing concerns for Liverpool has been the apparent physical decline of several key players. The demanding schedule, coupled with limited squad rotation, has led to fatigue, impacting performance levels. 

The period from October to December was particularly taxing, with fixtures piling up and little respite for the prominent team members. This relentless run has taken its toll, resulting in diminished intensity in recent encounters.​

In the Carabao Cup Final against Newcastle, Liverpool appeared lethargic, struggling to match their opponents’ energy and physicality. 

Manager Arne Slot acknowledged this disparity, noting, “This game had only to do with playing duels… you cannot even judge if we were tired physically because we could not press them.” 

The inability to engage effectively in competition and maintain pressing intensity is indicative of a squad grappling with fatigue.​

Pressing Inefficiencies

Liverpool’s identity under Slot has been characterized by a high-pressing game, aiming to suffocate opponents and regain possession swiftly. 

However, recent encounters have exposed cracks in this system. Against PSG, they struggled to impose their pressing, allowing the French side to dictate play. PSG’s midfield, orchestrated by Vitinha, showcased technical prowess and composure, effectively bypassing Liverpool’s defensive intensity. 

Similarly, Newcastle’s approach in the Carabao Cup Final neutralized Liverpool’s pressing strategy. The Magpies’ ability to win 68% of aerial duels disrupted the Reds’ rhythm, forcing them to adapt to a more physical contest. 

Slot admitted, “There was nothing to press because they played over our press.” This tactical adjustment from opponents has left the squads less effective, exposing vulnerabilities in their defensive setup.

Disruptions in Build-Up Play

A key aspect of Liverpool’s success is their capability to build play from the back, using quick and precise passing to transition smoothly from defense to attack. 

However, recent meetings have seen a decline in accuracy and cohesion. In the Champions League clash with PSG, Liverpool’s build-up was frequently disrupted, leading to turnovers and counter-attacking opportunities for the opposition. 

Their lack of composure in possession, coupled with uncharacteristic errors, hampered their offensive endeavors.​ The absence of Trent Alexander-Arnold sidelined due to an ankle injury sustained against PSG, further exacerbated these issues. 

Alexander-Arnold’s vision and passing range are integral to Liverpool’s build-up play, and his lack of presence was felt acutely in the Carabao Cup Final. 

Mohamed Salah’s Dip in Form

Mohamed Salah has been Liverpool’s talisman, consistently delivering goals and a creative spark. 

However, recent performances have seen a noticeable dip in his form. In the Carabao Cup Final, he failed to register a single shot or create any chances – a first in his Liverpool career. This uncharacteristic behavior raises concerns about his current fitness level and its impact on the team’s attacking potency.​

Salah’s influence extends beyond goal-scoring. His movement and ability to draw defenders also create space for teammates. 

A subdued Salah allows opponents to focus on other attacking threats, disrupting Liverpool’s offensive dynamics. Addressing the reasons behind his dip in form, whether physical or tactical, is crucial for the squads’ resurgence.​

Ryan Gravenberch’s Fatigue

Ryan Gravenberch has emerged as a pivotal figure in Liverpool’s midfield, offering industry, passing range, and tactical discipline. 

However, his increased workload has led to signs of exhaustion. Gravenberch has accumulated 2,573 minutes this season, almost doubling last year’s total of 1,848 minutes. 

Fatigue in such a crucial midfield role is affecting Liverpool’s possession and counter-pressing capabilities. 

Gravenberch’s ability to dictate tempo and break up opposition play is diminished when he’s below peak fitness. This leaves a less effective unit in the center of the pitch. Ensuring adequate rest and rotation are essential to maintaining the balance and effectiveness of Liverpool’s midfield.​

Limited Squad Rotation

Liverpool’s reliance on a core group of players has been a double-edged sword. While it fosters cohesion and understanding, it also leads to fatigue and increased injury risk. 

Slot’s approach to squad rotation has been conservative, averaging 2.3 changes per game, excluding cup fixtures. These limited changes have placed a heavy burden on the starting players, contributing to physical decline and performance dips.

The congested fixture list between October and December exacerbated this issue. The lack of fresh legs and competition for places has led to complacency and predictable patterns of play. 

Integrating fringe players and academy talents could provide much-needed rest for regular starters and introduce variability.

All Is Not Lost

​Liverpool’s recent defeats to Paris Saint-Germain and Newcastle have unveiled critical issues within the squad. These setbacks, while disappointing, should not overshadow the clubs’ remarkable PL campaign. 

Their dominance in the league, characterized by a substantial lead over competitors, proves the team’s resilience and quality.

As the season progresses, securing the Premier League title would be a monumental achievement, reflecting the squads’ excellence. Fans should recognize and celebrate this success, appreciating the efforts and performances that have positioned Liverpool at the pinnacle of English football this season.